Thanks for the shoutout! I couldn't agree more, but I think you've touched off a spark in my own mind, and I think I have a post to build on this somewhat.
In any event, you're right. What made the pulps great was the writing, not the marketing. We can ape the marketing all we like, but if we don't bring that grandeur, that action, that good writing, that wonder, then we're not worth much more than the latest translated isekai light novel.
And I know we're worth more than that.
I've seen too much good material from the PulpRev to believe otherwise.
RE: Between Pulp Wonders and Light Novel Trash