"Should" is the wrong question. It is not up to us to decide.
I don't know anything about Father Eli and I don't care to join his cult.
The fact is that damnation and salvation depend on you living a good life. If you do bad things and just SAY that you "accept Jesus Christ as your savior", you are still damned. If you do good things and don't pay attention to the Bible, God has ways of saving you anyway.
RE: 🇳🇬 Topic 128: Should a morally sound atheist be damned while an immoral Christian be saved? [Part 1 of 2]