In a theoretical sandbox world these ideas have merit, but when talking about a live blockchain there are additional factors that change the whole picture. Some of which are:
- BP's have operational costs. If an organization would put the same amount of funds into buying tokens from the market, they would achieve the same result as BP's producing blocks. This nullifies the effect BP's gains have on the network.
- Currently BP's are the best candidates for worker proposal funds, since they have the most expertise. By itself this is a good thing, but if we prohibit them from applying for these funds, we will end up paying more for an inferior result.
RE: Inflation, Centralization, and DPoS