This image is AI generated, This document, "An Analytical Overview of the Hive Blockchain Ecosystem," has been compiled and written with the assistance of an advanced AI model. The AI was provided with information and context to generate the comprehensive analysis presented herein. While the AI has aimed for accuracy and coherence based on its training data and the input provided, it is important to recognize that AI-generated content may occasionally contain inaccuracies or require further verification. This post should be considered a valuable resource for understanding the Hive ecosystem, but it is recommended that readers consult multiple sources and perform their own due diligence for critical decisions or in-depth understanding.
Post reward set to burn!
This account is managed by @bitcoinman
@bitcoinman shared this report a few days ago as a link to a PDF but now it and other reports will be posted on chain
Executive Summary
Hive is a decentralized, open-source blockchain platform engineered primarily for Web3 applications, with a distinct focus on social media, content creation, and community building. Launched in March 2020 following a contentious hard fork from the Steem blockchain, Hive was established by community members seeking to escape the perceived centralization threat posed by TRON's acquisition of Steemit Inc. Its core value proposition rests on principles of decentralization, censorship resistance, fast transaction speeds (3-second blocks), and a unique "fee-less" transaction model enabled by Resource Credits (RCs) tied to staked HIVE (Hive Power).
Technologically, Hive utilizes a Delegated Proof of Stake (DPoS) consensus mechanism, where elected "Witnesses" produce blocks and govern key network parameters. This enables high throughput suitable for social interactions but carries inherent centralization risks if not carefully managed through community vigilance and governance structures like the Decentralized Hive Fund (DHF). The DHF allocates a portion of inflation to fund community-approved development and ecosystem proposals, fostering decentralized growth.
Hive employs a dual-token system: HIVE, the liquid governance and utility token, and Hive Backed Dollars (HBD), an algorithmic stablecoin pegged to the USD. HIVE can be staked as Hive Power (HP) to gain influence (voting power) and generate RCs. Content creators and curators are rewarded through a "Proof of Brain" mechanism, receiving HP and HBD based on community upvotes. HBD also offers an on-chain savings feature with a Witness-set interest rate.
The Hive ecosystem is mature and diverse, hosting hundreds of decentralized applications (dApps), particularly in social media (e.g., PeakD, Ecency), gaming (e.g., Splinterlands), NFTs (e.g., NFTShowroom), and video (e.g., 3Speak). Its community, forged during the Steem fork, demonstrates strong cohesion around shared principles. However, quantitative data on user activity and developer metrics remains limited.
Compared to traditional social media, Hive offers user ownership, censorship resistance, and direct monetization. Versus other blockchain platforms, its strengths lie in its established ecosystem, speed, and fee-less model for social use cases. Weaknesses include the complexity of its tokenomics and governance for newcomers, potential DPoS vulnerabilities, algorithmic stablecoin risks associated with HBD, and challenges in achieving mainstream adoption. The platform's contentious origins and brand confusion with unrelated entities also present market perception hurdles. Hive represents a significant experiment in community-driven blockchain governance and a viable, albeit niche, platform for decentralized social interaction and content monetization. Its future depends on continued innovation, community engagement, and navigating the challenges of scalability and market visibility.
1. Introduction: The Hive Blockchain Defined
The Hive blockchain represents a distinct ecosystem within the broader landscape of distributed ledger technologies. It is fundamentally an open-source, decentralized blockchain platform conceived and engineered to serve as foundational infrastructure for Web3 applications.[1] While capable of supporting various decentralized applications (dApps), its primary design focus and subsequent ecosystem development have centered heavily on facilitating social media communities, content creation, and censorship-resistant communication.[2] Functionally, Hive aims to act as a conduit between the paradigms of Web 2.0 and the emerging Web 3.0, offering familiar social functionalities underpinned by blockchain principles.[3]
The core purpose driving Hive is the establishment of a robust social blockchain. It enables users to establish connections, securely share content, and participate in a network where contributions are recognized and rewarded.[1] Unlike traditional platforms where intermediaries capture the value generated by user activity, Hive implements mechanisms allowing users to earn its native cryptocurrencies (HIVE and HBD) directly for creating, curating, and engaging with content.[2] This operates under a concept often referred to as "Proof of Brain," where the collective judgment and engagement of the community, expressed through stake-weighted voting, determine the value and subsequent rewards distributed for content.[4]
Several key characteristics define Hive's value proposition and differentiate it within the market:
- Speed and Scalability: The blockchain is optimized for rapid transaction processing, boasting 3-second block times and near-instantaneous transaction confirmation facilitated by one-block irreversibility.[1] This architecture is designed to provide a seamless user experience comparable to traditional web applications and is intended to scale through layered solutions like sidechains while maintaining Layer-1 security.[2]
- "Fee-less" Transactions: Hive eschews conventional per-transaction gas fees common on many other blockchains. Instead, it utilizes a Resource Credit (RC) system.[1] Actions on the network consume RCs, which regenerate over time based on an account's staked HIVE (Hive Power). This model makes frequent interactions, such as posting, commenting, and voting, economically viable for users without direct monetary cost per action.[1] New accounts are typically provisioned with a starting amount of RCs to facilitate initial participation.[1]
- Decentralization: A foundational principle of Hive is its decentralized nature. There is no single corporate entity or organization exercising control over the network.[1] Governance and operation are intended to be community-driven, a direct consequence of the circumstances surrounding its creation.[1]
- Censorship Resistance: Stemming from its decentralized architecture, Hive is designed to be resistant to censorship. Content stored on the blockchain cannot be unilaterally removed or suppressed by a central authority, positioning it as a platform potentially conducive to free expression.[4]
It is crucial to distinguish the Hive blockchain (hive.io) discussed in this report from other entities sharing the "Hive" name. This analysis pertains exclusively to the DPoS social blockchain and its associated ecosystem. It is entirely unrelated to:
- Hive Digital Technologies (formerly HIVE Blockchain Technologies), a publicly traded company focused on Bitcoin mining and data centers.[11]
- The Hive AI, a company specializing in AI-driven content moderation solutions.[16]
- Hive Social, a separate mobile social media application unrelated to the blockchain.[17]
- hiveonline, a venture focused on financial inclusion and empowering the informal economy in Africa.[18]
- Blockchain.com, a cryptocurrency wallet and exchange service.[19]
The foundational philosophy underpinning Hive is arguably its most significant differentiator. The emphasis on decentralization, speed, the RC-based fee model, and censorship resistance is not merely a collection of technical features; it represents a deliberate ideological stance.[1] This philosophy emerged directly from the community's experience with the Steem blockchain and the perceived threat of centralization.[7] These principles directly address common criticisms leveled against both traditional Web 2.0 platforms (centralized control, opaque data monetization practices, censorship) and certain other blockchain implementations (high transaction costs, slow speeds). This strong ideological commitment appears to be a primary factor in cultivating and retaining its dedicated user and developer base.
Furthermore, the "fee-less" characteristic warrants nuance. While users do not expend HIVE or HBD tokens directly for standard transactions, the Resource Credit system intrinsically links network access to staked capital.[1] RCs regenerate based on an account's Hive Power (HP), meaning that significant or sustained network activity requires a corresponding investment in staked HIVE.[1] This creates an indirect cost – the opportunity cost of locking up HIVE in HP rather than having it liquid – and acts as a resource allocation mechanism. High-volume dApps or power users must possess or be delegated sufficient HP to generate the necessary RCs for their operations. Thus, while promoting accessibility for casual use, the RC system functions as an economic governor tied to stake, differentiating it from truly unlimited free transaction models and presenting potential scaling considerations for resource-intensive applications.
2. Origins: The Contentious Fork from Steem
The genesis of the Hive blockchain is inextricably linked to the history and evolution of the Steem blockchain. Understanding Hive requires examining the events that led to its creation as a community-driven hard fork.
Steem was launched in 2016 as a pioneering blockchain-based social media platform.[20] Its core innovation was a system designed to reward users with cryptocurrency (STEEM tokens) for creating and curating content through its primary interface, Steemit.[20] This model, promising direct monetization for user contributions, garnered significant initial interest and fostered a dedicated community.[20] However, over time, Steem faced challenges. Concerns arose regarding the manipulation of its reward system, leading to wealth concentration and potentially devaluing quality content.[20] Development on the main Steemit interface stagnated, user experience lagged behind competitors, and promised technological upgrades like Smart Media Tokens (SMTs) failed to materialize.[20] Governance became opaque, eroding user trust.[20] A significant point of underlying tension was the existence of a large "ninja-mined" stake – tokens acquired by Steemit Inc. at the network's inception under favorable conditions – which the community trusted would be used solely for ecosystem development.[7]
The situation escalated dramatically in February 2020 when Justin Sun, founder of the TRON Foundation, announced the acquisition of Steemit Inc.[5] This transaction included control over the substantial ninja-mined STEEM stake, estimated at around 20-30% of the total supply.[7] This immediately sparked widespread alarm within the Steem community. The primary fear was that Sun would leverage this massive stake to exert centralized control over the supposedly decentralized blockchain, fundamentally altering its governance and potentially merging it with the TRON ecosystem against the community's will.[7]
In response to these fears, elected community representatives ("Witnesses") on the Steem network initiated a defensive measure: soft fork 0.22.2. This software update temporarily froze the ninja-mined funds associated with Steemit Inc., preventing Sun from immediately using them to influence network governance.[20]
Sun's reaction was swift and decisive. Characterizing the community's soft fork as an attack by "hackers"[9], he coordinated with several major cryptocurrency exchanges – notably Binance, Huobi, and Poloniex (in which Sun had an interest) – to utilize STEEM tokens deposited by the exchanges' customers for voting on the Steem network.[7] This collective voting power was used to oust the incumbent community Witnesses and install new Witnesses controlled by or aligned with Sun.[20] These new Witnesses then implemented soft fork 0.22.5, reversing the community's previous fork and restoring Sun's access to the contested stake.[21] This action, widely described by the community as a "hostile takeover" or "Sybil attack," provoked outrage and solidified the community's opposition.[20] A period of intense "voting war" ensued as the community attempted to vote back their preferred Witnesses against Sun's considerable influence and resources.[20]
Facing a situation where reconciliation seemed impossible and centralized control appeared imminent, a significant portion of the Steem community, including many developers and prominent dApp teams, opted for a drastic solution: a hard fork.[5] This involved creating a new, independent blockchain based on the Steem codebase but operating under community control, free from the influence of Justin Sun and the contested stake.[7] This new blockchain was named Hive.
The Hive hard fork occurred on March 20, 2020.[3] Key aspects defined its launch and separation from Steem:
- Codebase: Hive initially launched as an exact copy of the Steem blockchain's code.[4]
- Airdrop: All existing STEEM account balances and content were duplicated onto the new Hive chain. STEEM holders received an equivalent amount of HIVE tokens in a 1:1 ratio.[10]
- Exclusion of Stake: Critically, the large ninja-mined stake controlled by Steemit Inc./Sun, along with stakes of certain accounts deemed complicit in the takeover, were explicitly excluded from the airdrop on the Hive chain.[9] This action was central to Hive's goal of establishing a decentralized foundation from the outset.
- Immediate Migration: Following the fork, a substantial portion of the active Steem community, including users, developers, and prominent dApps like Splinterlands and 3Speak, rapidly migrated their activities to the Hive blockchain.[15] Major interfaces like Steempeak rebranded to Peakd for the Hive ecosystem.[30] Initially, the HIVE token's market price quickly surpassed that of STEEM, reflecting market sentiment and the migration of value.[15] The period immediately following the fork saw continued friction, including actions by the Sun-controlled Steem witnesses to freeze STEEM funds belonging to prominent Hive supporters.[21]
The Steem/Hive split stands as a significant event in the history of blockchain governance. It serves as a potent case study demonstrating the potential for a determined community to enact technical sovereignty and migrate away from perceived hostile control, effectively choosing decentralization over an established chain and brand.[9] Ethereum founder Vitalik Buterin described the event as a potential 'watershed moment'.[22] However, the conflict also starkly illustrated the vulnerabilities inherent in Delegated Proof of Stake (DPoS) systems, particularly the risks associated with large, concentrated stakes and the potential for major exchanges to influence governance outcomes through the use of customer funds.[7] The very existence of Hive is a testament to these risks, and its subsequent governance enhancements, such as the Decentralized Hive Fund (DHF) and potentially a 30-day delay on staked voting power transfer[23], likely reflect lessons learned from this experience.
Furthermore, the fork was accompanied by a fierce battle over narrative and legitimacy. Justin Sun and his supporters framed the community's actions as theft or malicious hacking, while emphasizing their view of the transaction as a legitimate "partnership" and defending the "sanctity of private property" regarding the ninja-mined stake.[9] Conversely, the Hive community portrayed the fork as an act of liberation from a hostile corporate takeover, emphasizing the preservation of decentralization, community control, and freedom of speech.[9] The rapid migration of key dApps and active users to Hive suggests that the community's narrative resonated strongly within the existing ecosystem, proving crucial for establishing the new chain's viability and legitimacy.[21]
3. Core Technology Deep Dive
The Hive blockchain's architecture is designed to support its primary function as a high-throughput platform for social applications and content delivery. Its core technological components enable fast, fee-less interactions and decentralized operation.
Consensus Mechanism: Delegated Proof of Stake (DPoS)
Hive employs the Delegated Proof of Stake (DPoS) consensus mechanism, inherited and adapted from its Steem origins.[1] In this system, holders of the native HIVE token who have staked it – converting it into non-liquid Hive Power (HP) – use their stake weight to vote for individuals or entities known as "Witnesses".[2]
These elected Witnesses bear the primary responsibility for maintaining the blockchain's integrity and operation. Their core functions include validating transactions, producing new blocks according to a predetermined schedule, and ensuring the overall security of the network.[2] Typically, the top 20 Witnesses ranked by total HP vote weight are considered the active block producers, with a subset actively signing blocks in rounds. Beyond block production, Witnesses also play a crucial governance role by collectively setting certain adjustable blockchain parameters, such as the interest rate offered for HBD held in savings accounts.[1]
The choice of DPoS enables several key performance characteristics highly valued by Hive. It facilitates very fast block times – consistently cited as 3 seconds[1] – and allows for high transaction throughput compared to many Proof-of-Work systems. This speed is essential for creating a responsive user experience in social media applications, where delays can be detrimental to engagement.[1] DPoS is often presented as an efficient and battle-tested consensus model suitable for large-scale applications.[1]
Block Production and Finality
As mentioned, Hive produces new blocks every 3 seconds.[1] A significant feature contributing to its perceived speed is its implementation of one-block irreversibility.[8] This means that once a block is produced and accepted by the network (within milliseconds of the 3-second interval), it is considered final and cannot be reversed. This provides near-instant transaction confirmation, further enhancing the user experience for applications requiring rapid feedback.[8]
Transaction Model: Resource Credits (RCs)
A defining characteristic of Hive's operation is its unique approach to transaction costs. Instead of requiring users to pay a direct fee (often called "gas") in the native cryptocurrency for every action (like posting, voting, or transferring tokens), Hive utilizes a Resource Credit (RC) system.[1]
Every account on the Hive blockchain possesses an RC pool. Performing actions on the network consumes a certain amount of RCs, with different actions having different RC costs based on the computational and storage resources they require. These RCs regenerate automatically over time.[1] The maximum RC capacity of an account, and thus its ability to transact on the network, is directly proportional to the amount of Hive Power (staked HIVE) it holds.[1] Users with more HP have larger RC pools and faster regeneration rates, allowing them to perform more actions more frequently.
This RC model creates the user experience of "fee-less" transactions for most typical social interactions, as casual users with even a modest amount of HP will likely have sufficient RCs for their daily activities.[1] It removes the friction of needing liquid tokens for every minor interaction, thereby encouraging participation and engagement.[1] To ease onboarding, new accounts are typically granted a small initial delegation of HP, providing them with a starting pool of RCs to begin interacting immediately.[1] However, users or applications with very high transaction volumes must ensure they possess or are delegated enough HP to sustain their required RC consumption.
Unique Technical Features
Beyond its core consensus and transaction model, Hive incorporates several features aimed at usability and functionality:
- Readable Wallet Addresses: Unlike the long, complex cryptographic addresses common on many blockchains, Hive utilizes human-readable usernames as wallet addresses.[1] An account's username serves simultaneously as their social handle and their unique identifier for sending and receiving tokens, significantly simplifying user interactions.[1]
- Proof of Brain (PoB): While fundamentally a socio-economic layer, PoB is deeply integrated with Hive's technology. It represents the mechanism through which the blockchain distributes rewards from its inflation pool.[4] The system leverages the collective intelligence and subjective judgment of the community, expressed through HP-weighted upvotes and downvotes on content (posts, comments).[4] Content typically remains eligible to earn rewards for a 7-day period after publication.[3] The rewards generated are then distributed algorithmically among the author and the curators (voters) based on their stake and voting patterns.
- Layered Solutions: Hive's architecture is designed with scalability in mind, incorporating the concept of layered solutions.[3] This suggests the use of Layer 2 sidechains or similar technologies to handle specific types of transactions or applications off the main chain, thereby increasing overall network capacity while relying on the main Layer 1 blockchain for ultimate security and data integrity.[3]
While DPoS offers significant advantages in speed and throughput, making it well-suited for Hive's social focus[1], it involves inherent trade-offs regarding decentralization. By concentrating block production and certain governance functions in the hands of a relatively small number of elected Witnesses (typically the top 20)[2], DPoS systems can be more vulnerable to collusion, capture, or censorship by a coordinated group compared to more broadly distributed consensus mechanisms like Proof-of-Work. The very history of the Steem/Hive fork, triggered by a perceived hostile takeover facilitated by exchange collusion and concentrated stake[7], serves as a stark reminder of this potential vulnerability. Hive's continued use of DPoS necessitates strong community vigilance, active participation in Witness voting, and robust governance mechanisms (like the DHF and potentially voting delays[23]) to mitigate these risks and uphold its core principle of decentralization.
The Resource Credit system, while marketed as "fee-less," functions as a sophisticated economic governor for network resource allocation.[1] By tying an account's transaction capacity directly to its staked HIVE (Hive Power), the RC system effectively prevents network spam and ensures that users or applications consuming significant network resources have a tangible, long-term investment in the platform's health and the value of its native token. It shifts the cost of network usage away from per-transaction micropayments towards an upfront capital commitment (staking HIVE), creating a different economic dynamic compared to traditional gas-based models and incentivizing long-term holding.
4. Hive Tokenomics: HIVE and HBD
The economic engine of the Hive blockchain is powered by a dual-token system, comprising the native cryptocurrency HIVE and the algorithmic stablecoin Hive Backed Dollars (HBD).[1] These tokens serve distinct but interconnected functions within the ecosystem, facilitating governance, rewards, and value transfer.
The HIVE Token
HIVE is the fundamental, liquid cryptocurrency of the Hive blockchain.[2] Its primary functions include:
- Governance: HIVE is the token used to exert influence over the network's direction. By staking HIVE, users convert it into Hive Power (HP), which grants voting rights for electing Witnesses and approving funding proposals submitted to the Decentralized Hive Fund (DHF).[1]
- Staking (Hive Power): HIVE can be "powered up" or staked, transforming it into Hive Power (HP).[2] HP is non-transferable and represents a user's vested interest or influence within the ecosystem. Higher HP translates to greater voting power in both governance (Witness/DHF voting) and content curation (determining reward distribution via upvotes/downvotes).[2] Crucially, HP is also the basis for generating Resource Credits (RCs), which are consumed when performing actions on the blockchain, thus linking network usage capacity to stake.[1] HP can be delegated (temporarily leased) to other accounts, allowing users to grant network capacity or voting influence without transferring ownership of the underlying HIVE.[7] Converting HP back into liquid HIVE requires a "power down" process, which occurs over a period of 13 weeks, with a portion of the HIVE becoming liquid each week.[7] This vesting period encourages long-term commitment.
- Transactions and Trading: Liquid HIVE can be transferred between users (e.g., for tips or payments) and is the primary form traded on external cryptocurrency exchanges.[1] While everyday actions are often covered by RCs, HIVE itself might be used for specific operations or transfers.
The Hive Backed Dollar (HBD)
HBD is designed as an algorithmic stablecoin intended to maintain a peg close to the value of one US Dollar (USD).[1] Its stability mechanism relies on on-chain conversion functions that allow users to convert between HBD and a defined value of HIVE, effectively being backed by the perceived value of the HIVE token supply and the blockchain's protocol rules.[1]
- Utility: HBD serves as a stable unit of account within the Hive ecosystem. It provides a less volatile medium for expressing rewards and potentially for use in decentralized finance (DeFi) applications built on Hive.[1] Content rewards are often paid out as a combination of HP and HBD.[2]
- HBD Savings: A prominent feature of HBD is the on-chain savings mechanism. Users can lock their HBD into a dedicated savings balance within their Hive wallet to earn interest.[1] The annual percentage rate (APR) for HBD savings is not fixed; it is a variable rate determined by the consensus vote of the elected Hive Witnesses.[1] This rate has historically been positioned as potentially offering yields significantly higher than traditional savings accounts or even other crypto stablecoin yields, making it an attractive feature for capital preservation and passive income generation within the ecosystem.[1] However, shortly after the Hive fork, concerns were noted about the HBD peg's stability, a risk inherent in many algorithmic stablecoin designs.[21]
Token Distribution and Inflation
New HIVE tokens enter circulation through a controlled inflation mechanism.[4] The inflation rate is designed to decrease gradually over time; one source indicates a reduction of 0.01% every 250,000 blocks, equating to an approximate annual decrease of 0.5%.[7] This newly created HIVE funds the network's overall reward pool.
The distribution of this reward pool is allocated across several key areas[4]:
- Content Creators and Curators (Proof of Brain): A significant portion is allocated to reward users for creating valuable content (posts, articles, videos, etc.) and for curating content (discovering and upvoting valuable contributions). These rewards are typically distributed as a mix of Hive Power (HP) and Hive Backed Dollars (HBD).[2] The amount of reward is determined by the HP-weighted votes received within the 7-day reward window following publication.[3]
- Witnesses: Elected Witnesses receive a share of the inflation as compensation for their crucial role in producing blocks, validating transactions, and securing the network infrastructure.[4]
- Decentralized Hive Fund (DHF): A specific percentage of the inflation (often cited as 10%) is directed into the DHF.[1] This fund is used to support community-driven initiatives, including core blockchain development, dApp creation, marketing efforts, and other projects deemed beneficial to the Hive ecosystem, funded via a community proposal and voting system.[1]
The dual-token structure creates an intrinsic link between HIVE and HBD. Because HBD's value is algorithmically tied to HIVE through on-chain conversion mechanisms[1], the stability and perceived reliability of HBD depend heavily on the market value and stability of HIVE itself. Significant volatility or a sustained decline in the price of HIVE could potentially strain the conversion mechanisms and risk HBD deviating from its intended USD peg, a concern highlighted shortly after Hive's launch.[21] Maintaining confidence in the core HIVE asset is therefore crucial for the health of the entire tokenomic system.
The Witness-controlled interest rate on HBD savings[1] represents a powerful governance lever with direct economic consequences. By adjusting this rate, Witnesses can influence the demand for holding HBD versus HIVE or other assets. A high interest rate can attract capital into HBD savings, potentially strengthening the peg by increasing demand and reducing circulating supply.[1] It also provides a significant yield opportunity within the ecosystem. However, setting the rate excessively high could create long-term challenges. It might necessitate higher HBD issuance to cover interest payments, potentially adding inflationary pressure or straining the HIVE-HBD conversion mechanism if large amounts of HBD are later converted back to HIVE. This requires Witnesses to carefully balance the goal of incentivizing HBD holding with the long-term sustainability and stability of the entire tokenomic system.
Table 1: Hive Token Utility Summary
| Token | Primary Function(s) | How Acquired/Generated | Key Use Cases | Governance Role |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| HIVE | Liquid base currency, Trading, Powering up to HP | Inflation (Rewards), Trading on exchanges, Powering down HP | Transfers, Exchange trading, Staking into HP | Staked as HP for voting rights |
| Hive Power (HP) | Staked HIVE, Represents influence & network capacity | Powering up HIVE, Content/Curation rewards | Voting on content (curation), Generating Resource Credits (RCs), Delegation | Voting for Witnesses, Voting on DHF proposals |
| Hive Backed Dollar (HBD) | Algorithmic stablecoin (pegged to USD) | Content/Curation rewards, DHF proposal funding, Conversion from HIVE, Savings interest | Stable unit of account, Rewards payout, Savings vehicle, Potential DeFi use | Indirectly influenced by Witness votes (interest rate) |
5. Decentralized Governance Structure
Hive's governance model is designed to reflect its community-driven ethos, distributing decision-making power among stakeholders rather than concentrating it within a single entity. Key components include the elected Witnesses and the Decentralized Hive Fund (DHF).
The Role of Witnesses
As outlined in the technology section, Witnesses are the cornerstone of Hive's DPoS consensus.[2] Elected by HP holders through stake-weighted voting, they perform the essential technical function of producing blocks and validating transactions.[4] However, their role extends significantly into governance. The top elected Witnesses (typically 20 active producers) are responsible for maintaining the blockchain software and collectively deciding on protocol upgrades, often implemented via hard forks.[24] They also have the authority to adjust certain adjustable blockchain parameters that affect the entire network, a prime example being the setting of the interest rate for HBD held in savings.[1] This dual technical and governance function makes Witness positions highly influential within the ecosystem.
The Decentralized Hive Fund (DHF)
A critical element of Hive's decentralized governance and development model is the Decentralized Hive Fund (DHF).[1] This system allocates a dedicated portion of the blockchain's ongoing HIVE inflation (often stated as 10%) into a specific on-chain fund.[4] The purpose of the DHF is to provide funding for projects and initiatives that benefit the Hive ecosystem.[1] This can include core blockchain development, building new dApps or tools, marketing campaigns, community management, educational resources, and more.[1]
The DHF operates via a proposal system. Any community member can submit a detailed proposal outlining a project, its goals, timeline, and requested funding amount (paid in HBD).[1] These proposals are then subject to a vote by all HP holders.[1] Proposals that achieve sufficient net positive votes (based on stake weight) receive funding directly from the DHF pool according to their specified schedule.
The DHF is significant because it institutionalizes a community-controlled mechanism for funding ecosystem growth and maintenance.[1] It stands in contrast to traditional models where development roadmaps and funding are dictated by a central corporation (like Steemit Inc. on the original Steem chain).[10] The DHF aims to empower the community to directly shape Hive's future, fostering a sense of collective ownership and enabling grassroots innovation.[1] It is considered a cornerstone of Hive's claim to being a truly decentralized platform, born from the desire to escape the perceived constraints and influence of the Steemit Inc. structure.[10]
Decision-Making Processes
Major changes to the Hive protocol, such as hard forks that introduce new features or alter fundamental rules, require consensus among a supermajority of the top Witnesses.[24] More routine governance occurs through the ongoing actions of Witnesses adjusting parameters like the HBD interest rate[1] and through the continuous cycle of DHF proposal submission, voting, and funding.[1] Additionally, measures may exist to enhance governance security; shortly after the fork, a 30-day delay on the transferability of voting rights after staking was mentioned as a potential safeguard against rapid governance attacks or hostile takeovers, learning directly from the Steem experience.[23]
The DHF system, while embodying Hive's decentralized ideals, presents both opportunities and challenges. It provides a transparent and potentially powerful way to allocate resources towards valuable projects identified by the community itself.[1] This can foster innovation and address needs that might be overlooked in a top-down structure. However, decentralized funding mechanisms can also face difficulties. Achieving strategic alignment across numerous independent projects can be challenging. Voter apathy or low participation can hinder effective decision-making. There is also the potential for funding decisions to be swayed by popularity or effective campaigning rather than purely objective merit, or even potential misuse if oversight mechanisms are insufficient. The long-term success of the DHF model relies heavily on the sustained, active, and informed participation of the HP-holding community in evaluating and voting on proposals.
It is important to recognize that Hive's governance operates across multiple interconnected layers. It is not solely defined by Witness elections or DHF voting. The process begins with HP holders electing Witnesses based on their perceived competence, track record, and policy stances.[2] These Witnesses then make decisions on parameters like the HBD interest rate, which directly impacts user incentives and tokenomics.[1] Simultaneously, HP holders directly influence ecosystem development by voting on DHF proposals.[1] Underlying all of this is the "Proof of Brain" social consensus layer, where HP-weighted votes determine content rewards, driving user activity and engagement which ultimately underpins the network's value.[2] These layers are not independent; Witness actions affect tokenomics, DHF funding impacts ecosystem growth (and thus HIVE value), and the social reward system motivates the participation that gives HP its voting power. A comprehensive understanding of Hive governance requires appreciating this interplay between technical consensus, direct democracy (DHF), representative democracy (Witnesses), and social consensus (PoB).
6. The Hive Ecosystem Landscape
The Hive blockchain supports a notably mature and diverse ecosystem comprising hundreds of decentralized applications (dApps), communities, and projects that have been built upon its infrastructure.[1] Having been operational since early 2020 and inheriting a base from the Steem fork, Hive is described as having a "thriving, mature ecosystem"[1] and being "battle-tested"[8] by numerous applications globally. It hosts several dApps frequently cited among the most used in the broader Web3 space.[1] The ecosystem spans a wide range of categories, including social media, gaming, non-fungible tokens (NFTs), decentralized finance (DeFi), video streaming, and various tools.[32]
Key dApps and Projects by Category
Based on available information[1], the Hive ecosystem includes prominent examples across several domains:
- Social & Content Platforms: This is a core strength of Hive. Leading front-ends providing access to the underlying social blockchain include PeakD[1] and Ecency.[1] Hive.blog serves as another primary interface.[2] Specialized platforms cater to specific niches, such as 3Speak for decentralized video hosting and monetization[2], Liketu for image-focused social sharing[32], D.Buzz for microblogging[32], TravelFeed and truvvl for travel-related content[32], Engrave as a blogging platform service[32], STEMGeeks for science and technology content[32], Vimm for live streaming[32], Hive Tube for video content[32], Skate Hype focusing on skateboarding video content[32], Waivio combining social features with DeFi elements[32], and Hive Inbox for messaging.[32] This variety reflects Hive's origins and suitability for content-sharing applications.[4]
- Gaming & NFTs: Blockchain gaming is a significant pillar of the Hive ecosystem. Splinterlands, a collectible card game, is frequently highlighted as one of Hive's flagship applications and among the most popular blockchain games globally.[1] Numerous other gaming projects leverage Hive's fast and fee-less transactions, including Holozing[32], Wrestling Organization Online[32], dCrops (farming simulation)[32], dCity (city simulation)[32], Rising Star (music career simulation)[32], Ape Mining Club[32], Crypto Shots (first-person shooter)[32], EXODE (space exploration)[32], Muterra (monster taming)[32], King Of Duels[32], Terracore (strategy)[32], Immortal Creed[32], Genesis League Sports[32], and Rise of the Pixels.[32] The NFT sector is also well-represented, with marketplaces like NFTShowroom[32], NFTMart[32], NFTTunz (focused on music NFTs)[32], and platforms integrating NFTs like HivePunks (collectibles)[32], BlockTunes (music NFTs and DeFi)[32], HiveLIST (classifieds with NFT/DeFi integration)[32], DLux (supporting VR content and NFTs)[32], and Arcade Colony (NFTs and tools).[32]
- DeFi & Exchanges: While perhaps less prominent than social or gaming, DeFi elements exist on Hive. LeoDex[32] and Tribaldex[32] function as decentralized exchanges for Hive-based tokens (including Layer 2 tokens). Hivedex.io provides tools and potentially DeFi access.[32] The VSC Network aims to bridge Hive with smart contract capabilities, potentially expanding DeFi possibilities.[32] Furthermore, the native HBD savings mechanism[1] can be considered an on-chain DeFi primitive offering stablecoin yield.
- Tools & Infrastructure: Various tools support the ecosystem. HiveBuzz provides gamification and user statistics tracking.[32] Podping utilizes the blockchain for decentralized podcast update notifications.[32] The core feature of readable wallet addresses also serves as crucial user-friendly infrastructure.[1]
The relative maturity and diversity of Hive's ecosystem[1] can be attributed to several factors. Firstly, the hard fork allowed Hive to inherit the established user base, developer community, and existing dApps from Steem at its inception.[15] This provided an immediate foundation and momentum that newer blockchains often struggle to build organically. Secondly, Hive has maintained a clear focus on use cases where its core technological advantages – namely speed and the RC-based fee-less model – offer tangible benefits. Social media, content platforms, and gaming involve high volumes of interactions, often of low individual monetary value, making them well-suited to Hive's architecture.[1] This niche focus, leveraging inherent strengths, appears to have fostered sustained development in these areas.[1]
The significant presence and success of blockchain games, particularly Splinterlands[1], strongly suggest that gaming constitutes a critical pillar of activity within the Hive ecosystem. Beyond the core social and blogging applications that stem from its origins, gaming may represent the largest driver of transaction volume, user acquisition, and economic activity on the platform. The extensive list of diverse gaming and NFT projects[32] further underscores the suitability and adoption of Hive's infrastructure by the blockchain gaming sector. This highlights either a deliberate strategic emphasis or a powerful organic growth trend within the ecosystem focused on interactive entertainment.
Table 2: Prominent Hive dApps and Platforms
| dApp Name | Category | Brief Description | Mentioned Sources |
|---|---|---|---|
| PeakD | Social | Popular full-featured social media & blogging interface | 1 |
| Ecency | Social | Mobile-friendly social media & blogging interface | 1 |
| Splinterlands | Gaming, NFT | Leading blockchain-based collectible card game | 1 |
| 3Speak | Social, Video | Decentralized video platform with tokenized rewards | 2 |
| NFTShowroom | NFT | Marketplace for digital art NFTs | 32 |
| Liketu | Social | Image-focused social sharing platform | 32 |
| D.Buzz | Social | Microblogging platform | 32 |
| Rising Star | Gaming, NFT | Music career simulation game | 32 |
| dCity | Gaming, NFT | City simulation game with NFT elements | 32 |
| LeoDex | DeFi, Exchange | Decentralized exchange for Hive Engine tokens | 32 |
| Tribaldex | DeFi, Exchange | Decentralized exchange and token platform | 32 |
| Hive.blog | Social | Core blogging interface | 2 |
| TravelFeed / truvvl | Social | Platforms for travel content creators | 32 |
| Vimm | Social, Video | Live streaming platform | 32 |
| HiveBuzz | Tool | Gamification and user statistics tracking service | 32 |
| Podping | Tool | Decentralized notification system for podcast updates | 32 |
Note: This table lists a selection of prominent dApps mentioned in the sources; the full ecosystem contains many more projects.[1]
7. Community and Developer Ecosystem Analysis
Assessing the scale and vitality of Hive's community and developer ecosystem relies primarily on qualitative descriptions, as specific quantitative metrics are largely absent in the provided materials.
User Base Assessment
Sources describe Hive as having been operational "for a while" and possessing a "thriving ecosystem" populated by "hundreds of dapps, communities & projects".[1] It is positioned as a global network used by people "around the world".[8] A key attraction for users is the ability to earn cryptocurrency (HIVE and HBD) through active participation, such as content creation and curation, without needing an initial monetary investment.[2] While these descriptions suggest a substantial and engaged user base, concrete data regarding daily or monthly active users, retention rates, or detailed transaction volumes are not available in the referenced documents.
Developer Activity
The development landscape on Hive appears active, significantly supported by the Decentralized Hive Fund (DHF), which provides financial incentives for building on the platform.[1] The open-source nature of the blockchain[2] facilitates permissionless development. The existence of a wide array of projects across various categories[1] points to ongoing developer engagement. Shortly after the fork in 2020, it was noted that over 30 developers were contributing to the new ecosystem.[23] However, similar to user metrics, current quantitative data on the number of active developers, DHF proposal submission and success rates, or code repository activity levels are not provided.
Geographic Reach
Hive is characterized as a "global decentralized network"[8], implying users and participants are distributed internationally. No specific data regarding the geographic breakdown of users, developers, or Witness nodes is available in the source materials.
A significant factor shaping the Hive community is its origin story. The collective experience of the Steem fork – perceiving a threat to decentralization, organizing resistance, and executing a community-led migration – likely forged an unusually strong sense of shared identity and purpose among early adopters.[1] Narratives emphasizing community sovereignty ("community is in charge and cannot be bought"[22], "blockchain by the community for the community"[9]) were central to the fork's justification and success. This shared struggle and strong ideological alignment around principles of decentralization and censorship resistance may have fostered a more resilient and loyal community compared to platforms formed primarily around speculative investment or technological novelty alone. This cohesion could contribute to Hive's longevity and ability to weather market downturns.[1]
However, the analysis of Hive's community and developer ecosystem size and activity level is significantly hampered by a scarcity of concrete, verifiable metrics within the provided information. While terms like "thriving," "mature," and "hundreds of dapps"[1] paint a positive picture, their vagueness makes objective quantification difficult. Without access to data from block explorers, specialized analytics platforms, developer activity trackers, or community surveys – none of which are included in the source material – it is challenging to precisely gauge Hive's current scale, growth trajectory, or activity levels relative to competing platforms. Any assessment must therefore rely heavily on the qualitative descriptions available and acknowledge this inherent limitation in data availability.
8. Market Positioning and Competitive Analysis
Hive occupies a specific niche within the broader blockchain and social media landscapes. Its market position is defined by its unique history, technological choices, and core value propositions.
Comparison with Blockchain-Based Social Platforms
Within the Web3 space, Hive is positioned as one of the leading blockchains specifically tailored for social media and content creation.[1] Its relative longevity, described as a "mature ecosystem"[1], distinguishes it from many newer entrants in the decentralized social media (DeSo) sector. Its technical model, combining DPoS for speed with the RC system for fee-less interactions[1], offers a different user experience compared to platforms potentially relying on other consensus mechanisms or traditional gas fee structures. While specific competitors are not detailed in the provided sources, Hive's established presence and dedicated user base grant it a degree of incumbency within its niche.
Comparison with Traditional Social Media (Web 2.0)
Hive presents a fundamental alternative to centralized Web 2.0 platforms like Facebook, Twitter, YouTube, or Reddit. The core differentiators lie in its foundational principles:
- Decentralization: Unlike centrally controlled Web 2.0 platforms, Hive aims for community governance and operation.[1]
- User Ownership: Users theoretically retain greater control over their accounts and data, which are secured on the blockchain rather than solely on company servers.
- Censorship Resistance: The immutable nature of the blockchain makes content difficult for any single entity to remove or suppress.[4]
- Direct Monetization: Hive offers built-in mechanisms for users to earn cryptocurrency rewards directly for their content and curation activities, bypassing traditional advertising-based revenue models.[2]
- Algorithmic Transparency: Some Hive front-ends offer features like chronological feeds, contrasting with the often opaque and engagement-maximizing algorithms of Web 2.0 platforms.[17]
Strengths
Based on the analysis, Hive's key strengths include:
- Strong Decentralization Ethos & Censorship Resistance: This is a core ideological commitment stemming from its origins and a primary draw for its community.[1]
- Fast and "Fee-less" Transactions: The DPoS consensus and RC system provide a smooth user experience conducive to social interactions.[1]
- Mature and Diverse Ecosystem: Years of operation have resulted in a wide range of dApps, particularly in social and gaming, proving its capabilities.[1]
- Integrated Content Monetization: The Proof of Brain reward system offers a native way for users to earn value.[2]
- Resilient and Engaged Community: Forged in the Steem fork, the community shows strong cohesion around shared principles.[9]
- Decentralized Development Funding (DHF): Enables community-driven innovation and ecosystem growth.[1]
Weaknesses
Conversely, Hive faces several challenges and weaknesses:
- Complexity: The interplay of HIVE, HP, HBD, RCs, DPoS voting, and the DHF can present a steep learning curve for users unfamiliar with blockchain concepts.[1]
- Potential DPoS Centralization Vectors: Despite its ethos, the DPoS model remains susceptible to risks like Witness collusion or undue influence from large stakeholders or exchanges, as demonstrated by its own history.[7]
- HBD Peg Stability Risk: As an algorithmic stablecoin, HBD's peg to the USD relies on protocol mechanics and confidence in HIVE, carrying inherent risks of de-pegging during market stress.[21]
- Mainstream Adoption Hurdles: Bridging the gap to mainstream users remains difficult due to crypto onboarding friction, the niche appeal of decentralization for the average user, and competition from established Web 2.0 giants.[28]
- Quantitative Data Accessibility: The difficulty in accessing reliable, comprehensive metrics on user activity and ecosystem health hinders objective assessment and comparison.
Notable Criticisms and Controversies
Hive's history and operation are not without criticism or controversy:
- The Steem Fork: The very act of forking and the associated conflict with Justin Sun/TRON remain defining, and potentially polarizing, aspects of its identity.[15]
- Airdrop Exclusions: The decision to exclude the Steemit Inc. stake and other specific accounts from the initial HIVE airdrop was controversial, seen by some as confiscation.[15]
- Reward System Gaming: While Proof of Brain aims for meritocracy, like its predecessor Steem[20], reward systems based on voting can potentially be gamed or manipulated by coordinated actors or bots.
- Brand Confusion: The existence of multiple unrelated entities using the "Hive" name (Hive Digital Technologies, Hive AI, Hive Social) creates significant potential for brand confusion in the market, a point underscored by an early cease-and-desist letter from Hive Blockchain Technologies (now Hive Digital Technologies).[11]
Hive's market position appears firmly rooted in its niche as a platform for decentralized content, social interaction, and gaming. Its strengths align well with the needs of users and developers prioritizing censorship resistance, direct monetization, and low transaction costs for high-frequency interactions. However, these very strengths, particularly the reliance on crypto-native concepts like staking (HP), token rewards (HIVE/HBD), and decentralized governance (DPoS/DHF)[1], create barriers to entry and may limit its appeal to a broader mainstream audience uninterested in or intimidated by this complexity. As one commentary noted, Hive might be considered a "niche within a niche".[28] Its path to growth likely lies in deepening its dominance within these Web3 niches rather than attempting to directly challenge Web 2.0 incumbents for mass market share.
Furthermore, the dramatic circumstances of its creation, while instrumental in galvanizing its core community, may cast a long shadow on its perception in the wider market.[7] Narratives of conflict and hostile takeovers, even when Hive emerged as the community's chosen successor, could deter more risk-averse potential partners, investors, or enterprise users. Overcoming this historical baggage and navigating the persistent brand confusion[15] remain ongoing challenges for market positioning and recognition.
9. Conclusion and Future Outlook
Summary of Findings
Hive stands as a testament to community-driven action within the blockchain space. Born from a contentious fork driven by principles of decentralization and resistance to centralized control, it has established itself as a functional and mature Web3 platform.[1] Its core identity is built upon providing a high-speed[1], "fee-less" (via Resource Credits)[1] environment primarily for social media, content creation, and gaming applications.[1] Its Delegated Proof of Stake consensus enables performance, while its dual-token system (HIVE/HBD) facilitates rewards through the unique Proof of Brain mechanism and offers stablecoin utility.[1] Governance is distributed through Witness voting and the innovative Decentralized Hive Fund (DHF), which empowers community-funded development.[1] The ecosystem boasts a diverse range of dApps, with particular strength in social interfaces and blockchain gaming.[1]
Overall Assessment
Hive has largely succeeded in fulfilling its initial mission: creating a viable, community-governed alternative to the Steem blockchain, free from the centralized influence that triggered the fork. It offers a functional platform that delivers on its promises of speed and low-cost interactions, fostering a dedicated community and a demonstrably active ecosystem.[1] Its strengths – decentralization ethos, performance, integrated monetization, and community resilience – are significant assets within its chosen niches. However, it is not without weaknesses. The inherent complexities of its tokenomics and governance systems, the potential centralization risks associated with DPoS, the stability concerns surrounding the algorithmic HBD stablecoin, and the persistent challenges of achieving broader market adoption and clarifying brand identity remain pertinent issues.
Future Prospects & Challenges
Hive's future trajectory depends on its ability to leverage its strengths while mitigating its weaknesses. Potential growth areas include further expansion in blockchain gaming, where its infrastructure excels, potentially developing more sophisticated DeFi applications leveraging HBD and Layer 2 solutions, and utilizing the DHF effectively to attract innovative developers and projects that enhance user experience and utility.[1]
Key challenges remain formidable. Maintaining the delicate balance of decentralization within the DPoS framework requires continuous community vigilance and participation in governance. Ensuring the long-term stability and reliability of the HBD peg, particularly during market volatility, is crucial for user trust and ecosystem health.[21] Simplifying the user onboarding experience and communicating Hive's value proposition beyond the crypto-native audience are essential for expanding its user base. Overcoming market noise, competing effectively against both established Web 2.0 platforms and newer, potentially better-funded Web3 projects, and resolving lingering brand confusion[15] will require strategic effort. The continued success and evolution of the DHF as an engine for sustainable, community-aligned development will be a critical factor in Hive's long-term viability and relevance.[1]
Final Thought
Hive represents more than just another blockchain; it is a compelling, ongoing experiment in decentralized governance, community sovereignty, and the creation of alternative digital social spaces. It offers a distinct model that directly challenges the centralized paradigms of traditional social media, providing users with greater control, censorship resistance, and opportunities for direct value accrual. While it faces significant hurdles in achieving mass adoption and navigating the complexities of its own design within the volatile cryptocurrency market, its resilience, established ecosystem, and committed community position it as a noteworthy and enduring platform within the Web3 landscape. Its journey continues to provide valuable insights into the possibilities and challenges of building truly decentralized, community-driven digital networks.
Works cited
- Hive - The Blockchain & Cryptocurrency for Web3, accessed on April 22, 2025, https://hive.io/
- What is HIVE Token? $HIVE Crypto Coin Explained — A Comprehensive Blockchain Guide for Beginners | FerraraMedia on Binance Square, accessed on April 22, 2025, https://www.binance.com/en/square/post/18920136967634
- What is Hive (HIVE)? A Complete Guide to Its Blockchain Ecosystem - Bitrue FAQ, accessed on April 22, 2025, https://support.bitrue.com/hc/en-001/articles/41530938586521-What-is-Hive-HIVE-A-Complete-Guide-to-Its-Blockchain-Ecosystem
- What is Hive (HIVE)? The Blockchain Social Media Explained - Easy Crypto, accessed on April 22, 2025, https://hub.easycrypto.com/hive-blockchain
- What is Hive? The history/origin? ATH? | Kobmeister on Binance Square, accessed on April 22, 2025, https://www.binance.com/en-NG/square/post/18667032138762
- What makes hive Blockchain stand out from other social media platforms. - Waivio, accessed on April 22, 2025, https://www.waivio.com/@adaezeinchrist/what-makes-hive-blockchain-stand-out-from-other-social-media-platforms
- AN OVERVIEW OF HIVE - Pontem Network, accessed on April 22, 2025, https://pontem.network/posts/an-overview-of-hive
- Hive - The Blockchain & Cryptocurrency for Web3 - Hive.io, accessed on April 22, 2025, https://hive.io/about/
- About the Hive Project | GetBlock.io, accessed on April 22, 2025, https://getblock.io/blog/about-the-hive-project/
- HIVE - the worlds first decentralized social media network : r/CryptoCurrency - Reddit, accessed on April 22, 2025, https://www.reddit.com/r/CryptoCurrency/comments/fls7c3/hive_the_worlds_first_decentralized_social_media/
- HIVE Digital Technologies Ltd, accessed on April 22, 2025, https://www.hivedigitaltechnologies.com/
- Investors :: HIVE Digital Technologies, accessed on April 22, 2025, https://hivedigitaltechnologies.com/investors/
- HIVE Blockchain Technologies Ltd.: Exhibit 99.3 - Filed by newsfilecorp.com - SEC.gov, accessed on April 22, 2025, https://www.sec.gov/Archives/edgar/data/1720424/000106299321008894/exhibit99-3.htm
- HIVE Digital's move highlights Texas' renewed rise as a crypto hub - San Antonio Report, accessed on April 22, 2025, https://sanantonioreport.org/cryptocurrency-mining-firm-moves-headquarters-from-canada-to-san-antonio/
- HIVE - CryptoMarketsWiki, accessed on April 22, 2025, https://crypto.marketswiki.com/index.php?title=HIVE
- Hive AI: AI to Understand, Search, and Generate Content, accessed on April 22, 2025, https://thehive.ai/
- Hive Social, accessed on April 22, 2025, https://www.hivesocial.app/
- hiveonline – empowering the African informal economy, accessed on April 22, 2025, https://www.hivenetwork.online/
- Wallet | Login - Blockchain.com, accessed on April 22, 2025, https://login.blockchain.com/
- What the hell happened to Steem? - Hive, accessed on April 22, 2025, @beggars/what-the-hell-happened-to-steem
- What Are Steem and Hive? A Comparison of Both Decentralized Content Blockchains, accessed on April 22, 2025, https://cryptobriefing.com/what-are-steem-hive-comparison-both-decentralized-content-blockchains/
- Steem successfully forks to Hive blockchain - Brave New Coin, accessed on April 22, 2025, https://bravenewcoin.com/insights/steem-successfully-forks-to-hive-blockchain
- Steem Successfully Forks Creating “Hive” Blockchain - Crypto Briefing, accessed on April 22, 2025, https://cryptobriefing.com/steem-successfully-forks-creating-hive-blockchain/
- Inside Tron's Steem Takeover Attempt and the Birth of the Hive Blockchain | HackerNoon, accessed on April 22, 2025, https://hackernoon.com/inside-trons-steem-takeover-attempt-and-the-birth-of-the-hive-blockchain-ya1g63249
- Steem Community Resists Takeover, Hard Fork Launches Hive Network - Cointelegraph, accessed on April 22, 2025, https://cointelegraph.com/news/steem-community-resists-takeover-hard-fork-l
Launches-hive-network
- Justin Sun's Steem locks user funds - CoinGeek, accessed on April 22, 2025, https://coingeek.com/justin-suns-steem-locks-user-funds/
- Justin Sun Recounts Steem-Hive Hard Fork at Virtual Blockchain Week - Cointelegraph, accessed on April 22, 2025, https://cointelegraph.com/news/justin-sun-recounts-steem-hive-hard-fork-at-virtual-blockchain-week
- Fork fork and Away: Hive and the strange Effect Justin Sun has on the Awareness of Steem, accessed on April 22, 2025, https://steemit.com/steem/@cpufronz/fork-fork-and-away-hive-and-the-strange-effect-justin-sun-has-on-the-awareness-of-steem
- Steem vs Tron: The rebellion against a cryptocurrency empire - Decrypt, accessed on April 22, 2025, https://decrypt.co/38050/steem-steemit-tron-justin-sun-cryptocurrency-war
- Hive Hard Fork is Successful, STEEM Crashes Back to Earth - Cointelegraph, accessed on April 22, 2025, https://cointelegraph.com/news/hive-hard-fork-is-successful-steem-crashes-back-to-earth
- Steem - It appears not everyone will be leaving for HIVE... - Steemit, accessed on April 22, 2025, https://steemit.com/steem/@jrcornel/steem-it-appears-not-everyone-will-be-leaving-for-hive
- Hive Ecosystem - Hive - The Blockchain & Cryptocurrency for Web3, accessed on April 22, 2025, https://hive.io/eco/