Welcome to the 11th Make a Minnow voting post!
This initiative is about awarding a minnow who creates qualty content and supports fellow content creators in a community under the PAL/MSP umbrella by giving that minnow a delegation prize as a reward for their efforts!
The prize this round will be a 5000 SP delegation for four weeks!
Giving our minnows the opportunity to have increased curation influence benefits the entire Steemit ecosystem and should be considered a great honour.
This Second post announces the start of the Voting Round and lists the nominees that have been selected.
Eligible voters that nominated during the Nomination Round have one week to comment on this post with their vote from the list of selected nominees.
Update: prechi (37 nominations) has been disqualified due to plagiarism.
More details below.
This week our top three contenders are @soundwavesphoton, @gokhan83kurt, and @meno! The nominations were as follows for our top three:
@soundwavesphoton (10 nominations)
@diebitch
@llfarms
@soulturtle
@torico
@kodaxx
@kerlund74
@tanishqyeverma
@inquiringtimes
@asonintrigue
@dante31
@gokhan83kurt (8 nominations)
@biriki3
@bircan
@onderakcaalan
@ozkanozturkk
@gulfuren
@nurtensul
@mesafe
@baycan
@meno (5 nominations)
@jfolkmann
@kubbyelizabeth
@staceyjean
@uniwhisp
@aggroed
These nominators are also eligible to vote in the next round as they have voted for an eligible candidate who did not make it into the top three: @r0nd0n @sunravelme @embesilikat @clayboyn
More on the disqualification
I, @eturnex, have the duty to inform you that prechi has two plagiarised posts in the last week. The Organizers and I, in consultation with contest founders, have decided to disqualify the nominee and temporarily ban the nominee from participation in upcoming MaM contests. The ban is temporary to allow the disqualified party a chance to demonstrate they have reformed.
Plagiarism is a breach of the Make A Minnow rules. While plagiarism is not explicitly mentioned at this time, the intepretation of the rules is at the sole discretion of the MaM Organizers. Here is how I, @eturnerx, have chosen to interpret plagarism in light of the rules: Nominees must exemplify the values of MSP/PALNet, make a postivie contribute to the community and create quality content. Plagiarism does not exemplify the values of the MSP/PALNet, is not a positive contribution to the community, and is not quality content. Therefore, I take the rare step of disqualifying the nominee.
A summary of the effects of the disqualification:
- prechi is disqualified from MaM#11
- prechi cannot be nominated for another Make A Minnow contest until after 1 May 2018
- prechi may not nominate (and by extension vote) in another Make A Minnow contest until after 1 May 2018
- Those that nominated prechi are not eligible to vote in MaM#11
- The nominee with the fourth most valid nominations is now in the voting round
- I will flag/upvote to try organise the comments.
If you have an comments about this decision, then please discuss in the comments below.
Ineligible nominations
We also had a number of ineligible nominations as they were not delegating/nominated someone who was not eligible, these users are not eligible to vote in this round:
@predict-win, @oguzhangazi, @turistomer, @schubes, @mistacute, @fearless97, @jesusagon, @robmenzies, @paradigmprospect, @yohannagotopo, @jeander, @turkishcrew, @johangericke, @clairefabella, @thermoplastic, @kathleenscarboro, @adesojisouljay, @yasirgawad, @aduragbemi, @chemmy, @ifunanyaikemma, @winstonomeruah, @demonsthenes, @mnine3, @artizm, @drasad, @sirsticks, @maxdah, @mnallica, @aidefr, @apiprincz, @juli11157, @juli1, @vickyrich, @shizzy, @dtwo, @dhayor, @iamthegrey, @olajidekehinde, @murphylee, @mzajoke
The following nominators are not eligible to vote because their nominated nominee has been disqualified:
@jerryboy4luv, @kodeblacc, @cryptomaxdagr8t, @adabless, @gloeze, @dee-y, @julietisrael, @emekacollins, @ajremy, @oyinoza, @dinah4sure, @amec, @onos, @arcjen02, @masterpiz, @levitated-mind, @ewuoso, @jblsignature, @utomobong, @unireal1, @sirsticks, @xplore, @stevenson7, @sussan, @sparklez, @princeyk, @sciencegeek, @princeso, @mritsnobigdeal, @fejiro, @kweenzykruzy, @dayjee, @tony-duke, @steemcenturion, @alisonudeme, @xpressng, @jadeturf
We ask nominators to exercise more care in who they nominate. Plagiarism does not exemplify the values of the MSP/PALNet, is not a positive contribution to the community, and is not quality content. Inappropriate nominations reflect badly on the Make A Minnow contest and upon the nominator themselves.
We trust all the members will vote carefully with the PAL (Peace, Abundance and Liberty) values in mind! Best of luck to all nominees that made it through to this round!
If you would like to review the guidelines for Make A Minnow please read through the post here
All users listed above who had eligible nominations may cast their vote in the comment section, also previous MaM winners are always eligible to vote! This is the voting post so please vote in the comments below! You have until this post pays out to complete this step.
Organizers: @juliakponsford, @clayboyn