Particle in a Double well potential: A molecular dynamics toy examp...

In my previous articles, we have seen many examples which demonstrated classical molecular dynamics simulations of bigger systems like

Today let us attempt something very simple. Very less math(or math that you can ignore and still you can understand most of the stuff!) and more intuitive explanation will be the focus of today's article. (Although this is what I strive always for... Don't know how successful I am in doing so. Do let me know via comments.) Let us try to get an intuition from this toy system.

The System

Think about a system where you have a hypothetical particle in a crowd of lot many smaller particles(ideally in the order of 1023, but lesser number will also work, which can be considered a large number. Why this number? Let that be a homework now.) The situation will be something like as below:

Image Source: Wikimedia, Author: Lookang, Author of computer model: Francisco Esquembre, Fu-Kwun and lookang, License: CC BY-SA 3.0

The small particles will have an inherent random motion in them where they collide each other and with the bigger particle too. Now this bigger particle will also exhibit a random motion due to this. This is typically called Brownian motion(The name from an 1827 biologist Robert Brown who observed via microscope that pollen grains jiggle in water) which emerges as a result of random walks. The classical molecular dynamics which we were doing in the past was very deterministic. Here we see randomness. Why so? Is there some inconsistency? There is no inconsistency. The thing is if each of these particles was allowed to move according to newtons laws(where we also know their initial positions and velocities) would exhibit some dynamics like this. The thing is when we have a lot of such trajectories we can try to model this uncertainty using randomness or noise terms. And gaussian noise is a good model to achieve this.

So if you don't want to track all of these nasty small particles you can resort to something called Langevin Dynamics. This is different from Classical Molecular dynamics. In classical molecular dynamics:

is the equation of motion. mass times acceleration is the force which is the negative gradient of potential energy U. We have explained these things before.

Now in the langevin formalism, the small particles become implicit. So the equation becomes:

where the second term in the right hand side of the equation is gamma(friction coefficient) times velocity and the third term is the noise term. R(t) is a zero mean, delta correlated stationary gaussian noise and scaling factor is where the temperature T comes in the picture. Intuitively we can assume that when the temperature is high the diffusion coefficient(D) of the bigger particle will be high and if the viscosity is high the diffusion coefficient of the larger particle will be lesser. There is a relation which Einstein derived in 1905 for this:

This is one of the earliest so called fluctuation-dissipation relation.

The potential decides what force the particle experiences. Now think about a double well potential like this below:

If you slice it in one dimension(at Y=0) you will see that it has 2 minimas:

This is why we are calling it double well potential. The form of the potential energy function is as below:

where X and Y are particle position coordinates.

Matlab code for the plotting potential:

clear; close all; clc
x=linspace(-2,2,25);
y=linspace(-2,2,25);
[X,Y] = meshgrid(x,y);
Z=4*(X-1).^2.*(X+1).^2 + Y.^2; % potential energy landscape
hs = surf(X,Y,Z); % Get surface object

Now imagine that our particle which experiences friction and kicks(noise) from the other particles and is also under influence of this particular potential energy . Depending on the temperature T, friction coefficient gamma and the barrier height of the potential(the peak between minimas) our particle will traverse in this energy landscape. Let us see that dynamics via a very simple simulation which we can setup in openMM.

The implementation of system using openMM toolkit

OpenMM is a collection of python packages which help users to create python scripts to run MD simulations. It is a toolkit from Vijay Pande group which pioneered the folding@home project.

Python Code(Which I wrote on Jupyter notebook initially):

%matplotlib inline
from __future__ import print_function
import numpy as np
import matplotlib.pyplot as plt
import simtk.openmm as mm#Imported numpy, plotting libraries and openmm
def run_simulation(n_steps=10000):
    "Simulate a single particle in the double well"
    system = mm.System()
    system.addParticle(1)# added particle with a unit mass
    force = mm.CustomExternalForce('2*(x-1)^2*(x+1)^2 + y^2')# defines the potential
    force.addParticle(0, [])
    system.addForce(force)
    integrator = mm.LangevinIntegrator(500, 1, 0.02)% Langevin integrator with 500K temperature, gamma=1, step size = 0.02
    context = mm.Context(system, integrator)
    context.setPositions([[0, 0, 0]])
    context.setVelocitiesToTemperature(500)
    x = np.zeros((n_steps, 3))
    for i in range(n_steps):
        x[i] = context.getState(getPositions=True).getPositions(asNumpy=True)._value
        integrator.step(1)
    return x
trajectory = run_simulation(25000)
ylabels = ['x', 'y']
for i in range(2):
    plt.subplot(2, 1, i+1)
    plt.plot(trajectory[:, i])
    plt.ylabel(ylabels[i])
plt.xlabel('Simulation time')
plt.show()
plt.hist2d(trajectory[:, 0], trajectory[:, 1], bins=(25, 25), cmap=plt.cm.jet)
plt.show()

Explanation of the code

What we are doing here is initiating a single particle which experiences the friction and kicks and evolves its positions via langevin integrator. system.addParticle(1) means adding a particle with unit mass, force = mm.CustomExternalForce('2*(x-1)^2*(x+1)^2 + y^2') is where you define the potential, integrator = mm.LangevinIntegrator(500, 1, 0.02) is where you define the bath temperature, gamma(friction coefficient=1) and step size(0.02). trajectory = run_simulation(25000) calls the simulation run for 25000 steps. and the rest is plotting step.

Results

The double well is very visible from the positions of x. The particle moves back and forth between 2 wells.

This is a histogram of x versus y coordinates. Again you can see that there are 2 valleys here.

Different cases

Let us think about a case where the temperature is very low. Let us put T=10K. The particle should not leave one minima, right? Let us see:

Indeed that is the case!

What should happen if we increase friction coefficient keeping T=500K? Let us put gamma=100.

Of course, the transitions became lesser in frequency! The effect of higher viscosity!

Now, what happens if we raise the barrier of potential. This was the potential: If I change 4 to 20, the barrier between wells will rise. Which means the particle will find it hard to jump the barrier. Let us repeat the experiment by only changing this parameter from the original experiment:

Indeed that is the case! So if you try to reconstruct energy landscape from the above case, it will give a biased profile. So one solution can be running the simulation longer. Let us try?

Instead of 25000 steps, let us run the simulation for 250000 steps.

See the symmetric well is very visible now! If you reconstruct the energy surface from here it will be a good estimate.

Code Repository

All code available here:

https://github.com/dexterdev/STEEMIT/tree/master/Particle_in_double_well_potential

Installing the openMM python library

To install openMM, just do:
conda install -c omnia -c conda-forge openmm
assuming you have installed anaconda python package in a 64 bit linux machine. For other cases and more details see instructions here.

References, links, and further reading

Some MD fundamentals:
A book reference: "Statistical Mechanics: Theory and Molecular Simulations" by Mark E. Tuckerman
http://openmm.org/

#steemSTEM

#steemSTEM is a very vibrant community on top of STEEM blockchain for Science, Technology, Engineering and Mathematics (STEM). If you wish to support steemstem visit the links below:

Have you voted for steemSTEM Witness?

Quick link for voting for the SteemSTEM Witness(@stem.witness)

Delegation links for @steemstem give ROI of 65% of curation rewards

(quick delegation links: 50SP | 100SP | 500SP | 1000SP | 5000SP | 10000SP).

Also, visit and create your STEM posts using steemstem app here: https://www.steemstem.io
You can also set @steemstem as beneficiary.

All images without image sources are my creations :)

Particle in a Double well potential: A molecular dynamics toy example using openMM toolkit

The System